Historical Archive Notice
Reconstructed from archived web captures of Television Without Pity (c. 1998-2014) and Brilliant But Cancelled. Content reflects opinions and commentary as originally published.
American Idol
Season 1
- S01E12: First Dubya, now this by Shack
Season 2
- S02E07: Moon Over Miami by Shack
- S02E10: Boobies Over Booty by Shack
- S02E17: Throwing The Paybee Out With The Bathwater by Shack
- S02E20: What Shack needs now is a frickin' break! by Shack
- S02E20: An Idol Ain't Nothin' But A Sandwich by Shack
- S02E21: From Justin To Kelly by Shack
- S02E21: From Justin To Kelly by Shack
- S02E22: Clay Aiken: "Measure of a Man" by Shack
- S02E22: Clay Aiken: "Measure of a Man" by Shack
- S02E23: An American Idol Christmas by Shack
- S02E24: Ruben Studdard: "Soulful" by Shack
- S02E24: Ruben Studdard: "Soulful" by Shack
- S02E25: World Idol , Part I by Shack
- S02E26: World Idol , Part II by Shack
Season 3
- S03E13: The Spazz Singer by Shack
- S03E14: Ain't Nothing Like the Real Thing by Shack
- S03E15: Honky Tonk Blahs by Shack
- S03E16: Buffoons in a Ten-Cent Motown by Shack
- S03E17: I Guess That's Why They Call It The Blues by Shack
- S03E18: From Dusk Till Jon by Shack
- S03E19: When Will I Scold You Again? by Shack
- S03E20: Miami Ow Machine by Shack
- S03E21: The Final Five 2004 by Shack
- S03E21: Another One Bites the Dust by Shack
- S03E21: Another One Bites the Dust by Shack
Season 4
- S04E02: Mentally Ill Is The New Hilarious, Part II by Jacob
- S04E03: Mentally Ill Is The New Hilarious, Part III by Jacob
- S04E04: "So What Are You Doing Here?" by Jacob
- S04E05: Knock It Off (The Box) by Jacob
- S04E07: Compared To What? by Jacob
- S04E09: Ziggy Played Guitar by Jacob Clifton
- S04E10: "She Had Style! She Had Flair! She Got Tossed!" by Jacob
- S04E11: One Flea Spare by Jacob Clifton
- S04E11: grade episode One Flea Spare by Jacob Clifton
- S04E15: Rock & Roll Suicide by Jacob Clifton
- S04E19: Some People Wait A Lifetime For Something To Happen by Jacob Clifton
- S04E20: Skeptacular! Skeptacular! Part II by Jacob
- S04E34: Fake Jesus Can't Be Fooled (Don't Even Think It!) by Jacob
Season 5
- S05E01: Bo Bice Is The New Clay Aiken, Part I by Jacob Clifton
- S05E02: Bo Bice is the New Clay Aiken, Part II by Joe R
- S05E02: Bo Bice is the New Clay Aiken, Part II by Joe R
- S05E03: Bo Bice is the New Clay Aiken, Part III by Jacob Clifton
- S05E03: Bo Bice is the New Clay Aiken, Part III by Jacob Clifton
- S05E03: Bo Bice is the New Clay Aiken, Part III by Jacob
- S05E04: Hollywouldn't by Joe R
- S05E05: Hollydidn't by Jacob Clifton
- S05E07: Suck It, Sasha Cohen! Part II by Jacob Clifton
- S05E09: ...Love, Rupert Murdoch, Part I by Jacob Clifton
- S05E10: ...Love, Rupert Murdoch, Part II by Joe R
- S05E11: ...Love, Rupert Murdoch, Part III by Jacob
- S05E12: Don't Raise Your Eye by Joe R
- S05E13: Bull On Parade by Jacob Clifton
- S05E16: Top Nine: You Botoxed Kenny! You Bastards! by Jacob
- S05E17: Top 8 -- Another One Bites the Dust by Joe R
- S05E18: Top 7 -- Paula, I Think I've Got Something To Say To You by Jacob
- S05E21: Top 4 -- The King Is Gone (So Are You) by Jacob
- S05E24: The Princess & The Basket Case by Jacob Clifton
Season 6
- S06E01: Act Your Age, Not Your...On Second Thought, Don't Act Your Age by Joe R
- S06E02: Take Seattle To The Zoo by Jacob Clifton
- S06E03: Don't Cry Out Loud by Joe R
- S06E03: Don't Cry Out Loud by Joe R
- S06E04: Watergate Still Kind Of Bothers Me by Jacob Clifton
- S06E05: Programmed To Receive by Jacob Clifton
- S06E06: Forget The Alamo by Joe R
- S06E07: Leftover Pie by Joe R
- S06E12: Goodbye, Lipless and Shiny-Face by Joe R
- S06E18: King Jeremy The Wicked Sent You Home by Joe R
- S06E34: Parting Is Such Sweet Sorrow by Couch Baron
- S06E37: Television City City Limits by Joe R
- S06E40: The Young Americans by Jacob Clifton
Season 10
- S10E01: James Franco in the Mouth Area by Jacob Clifton
- S10E27: But He Breaks Just Like a Little Consumptive by Jacob Clifton
- S10E27: But He Breaks Just Like a Little Consumptive by Jacob Clifton
Season 12
- S12E07: Hot Man on Man Action by M. Giant