After blindsiding Aras, Vytas tries to be magnanimous but Tina tells everyone that they now will have five votes against them on the jury. Her, Katie, Vytas, Aras, and who else? Then it comes out that Aras had made alliances with pretty much everyone, so that's why they voted him out. After that, Tina tells Katie to make her own gameplan, because Tina has a huge target on her and will only drag Katie down.
First Immunity Challenge is eating gross things. It all comes down to Monica and Gervase having to eat giant grubs, just like Gervase failed to do in the first season. And Monica wins immunity. Everyone talks about splitting the vote between Vytas and Katie, and Vytas begs to get fewer votes. Tyson is somewhat swayed by the idea of keeping another male and getting rid of a potential female-alliance member as well as one of a pair.
At Tribal Council, Vytas must know he's going because he burns some SERIOUS bridges with Monica, with Tyson and with Gervase. And Vytas does in fact join his brother on Redemption Island. The men were supposed to vote for Vytas and the women for Katie but Monica gets pissed and switches her vote to Vytas. It doesn't affect the outcome but it does piss some people off.
Right away, we get another Immunity Challenge. They have to balance a sword on a shield and then balance a stack of coins on top of that. It comes down to Hayden, Tyson, and Katie, and the two men's stacks drop at almost exactly the same time leaving Katie as the winner.
When they return to camp, Tina heads out to look for the Hidden Immunity Idol since she knows it's probably her only chance to stay in the game. Tyson, Hayden, and Caleb follow her to prevent her from finding it or possibly find it as well. Except Tyson knows she's not going to find it, because he has it. So then there's a weird standoff in the jungle and Tina tries to make them think she might have found the Idol.
At Tribal Council, Tina campaigns hard against Monica sucks and tries to pretend she has the Idol. Boy, she must feel dumb watching this now, knowing that Tyson actually had it all along. And then after all that talk, they vote out Tina anyway.